Reactivated Lead Close Rate: How to Win More Deals From Your Existing Pipeline

New leads are great, but your fastest growth often comes from the leads you already earned. In this lesson, you’ll learn how to measure your Reactivated Lead Close Rate (%), spot what’s working by month, lead source, and follow-up method, and use simple visuals to decide where your team should double down (and what follow-up is just creating activity).

Download the Excel file used in this tutorial:

Reactivated Lead Close Rate (%)

1. Add the required reactivation and close fields to your dataset

  • In your dataset, make sure you have reactivation columns (starting around column AG in the video).
  • Minimum fields needed:
    • Reactivation date and time
    • Reactivation channel
    • Reactivation reason
    • Close status (won or lost)
    • Close date and time
    • Close reason

2. Create helper columns that power the KPI calculations

  • Create a “Reactivated Lead Source” helper column:
    • If Reactivation Date/Time is blank, return blank
    • Otherwise return the original Lead Source
  • Create a “Reactivated Subsource” helper column the same way (optional in the video, but shown)
  • Create a “Reactivation Month” helper column:
    • If Reactivation Date/Time is blank, return blank
    • Otherwise extract the month name using TEXT(date_cell,”mmmm”)
  • Create a “Was Reactivated” flag column (0/1):
    • If Reactivation Date/Time is blank, return 0
    • Otherwise return 1
  • Create a “Reactivated Won” flag column (0/1):
    • If Was Reactivated = 1 and Final Status = Closed, return 1
    • Otherwise return 0

3. Build the monthly summary table

  • Create a Month column:
    • Type January and drag down through December
  • Create “Reactivated” count by month:
    • Use COUNTIFS() to count rows where:
      • Reactivation Month = the month in your summary table
      • Was Reactivated flag = 1
  • Create “Won” count by month:
    • Use SUMIFS() to sum the Reactivated Won flag where:
      • Reactivation Month = the month in your summary table
    • Because it is a 0/1 column, sum gives you the count of wins

4. Calculate the Reactivated Lead Close Rate (%)

  • In the monthly summary table:
    • Close Rate = Won ÷ Reactivated
  • Format as a percent using Ctrl + Shift + 5
  • Copy the formula down for all months

5. Calculate the true 3-month moving average

  • Do not average the last 3 close rate percentages
  • Instead calculate:
    • Sum of Won for the last 3 months ÷ Sum of Reactivated for the last 3 months
  • Drag down so the 3-month window rolls forward each month
  • This prevents “average of averages” errors when monthly volumes differ

6. Create the combo chart with a secondary axis

  • Select the monthly columns you want charted:
    • Reactivated count
    • Won count
    • Close Rate percent
    • 3-month moving average percent
  • Insert a chart:
    • Insert → Recommended Charts
    • Then switch to All Charts → Combo
  • Set:
    • Reactivated and Won as columns on the primary axis
    • Close Rate and 3-month average as lines on the secondary axis
  • Title suggestion used in the video:
    • “Reactivated Close Rate by Month”
  • Optional labeling:
    • Add data labels to just one line series to avoid clutter
    • Resize or reposition labels if they overlap

7. Build the lead source by reactivation channel heat map

  • Create a unique list of Lead Sources:
    • Use UNIQUE() on the lead source field from your table
    • Copy → Paste Values (Ctrl + Shift + V)
  • Create a unique list of Reactivation Channels:
    • Use UNIQUE() on the reactivation channel field
    • Copy → Paste Values
    • Sort A to Z if desired
  • Transpose the reactivation channels so they run across the top:
    • Copy → Paste Special → Transpose (or the shortcut shown in the video)

8. Populate the heat map denominator

  • For each Lead Source x Reactivation Channel cell:
    • Use COUNTIFS() to count reactivated leads where:
      • Was Reactivated flag = 1
      • Reactivation Channel = the column header
      • Reactivated Lead Source = the row label
  • Lock cell references correctly so you can copy across and down:
    • Lock the row for the header reference
    • Lock the column for the lead source reference
  • If dragging causes table column references to shift incorrectly:
    • Copy and paste formulas instead of dragging

9. Calculate the heat map close rate with IFERROR

  • Close Rate = Won Reactivations ÷ Reactivations
  • The numerator uses the same base logic but adds a “Closed” requirement
  • Wrap the full formula in IFERROR():
    • If divide-by-zero occurs, return a dash “-”
  • Copy across and down using copy/paste (not drag) for table stability
  • Key interpretation shown in the video:
    • Dash means no denominator (no reactivations happened)
    • Zero means reactivations happened but none closed

10. Add a target close rate and conditional formatting

  • Create a target cell (example used: 40%)
  • Conditional format the heat map:
    • Highlight cells less than the target:
      • Home → Conditional Formatting → Highlight Cells Rules → Less Than
      • Reference the target cell
  • Format dashes separately so they do not look like failures:
    • Conditional Formatting → Text that contains → “-”
    • Apply a neutral fill (gray) to visually separate “no data” from “below target”

11. Display “Target-40%” without breaking the numeric value

  • Keep the cell as a numeric percent
  • Use custom number formatting:
    • Ctrl + 1 → Number → Custom
    • Add text in quotes before the percent format, like:
      • “Target-“0%
  • This displays the label while keeping the value usable in rules and formulas

Reactivated Lead Close Rate (%)

Q1. What is Reactivated Lead Close Rate (%)?
Reactivated Lead Close Rate (%) measures how often previously contacted leads that get re-engaged (reactivated) end up closing. It helps sales teams understand how effective their follow-up and reactivation efforts are at turning “old pipeline” into revenue.

Q2. Why should I track reactivated leads separately from new leads?
Because reactivated leads behave differently than brand-new leads. Tracking them separately shows whether your team is actually winning from follow-up, and it helps you avoid spending time on “new lead activity” when your best wins are sitting in your existing pipeline.

Q3. What will this video help me analyze?
This tutorial shows how to break the KPI down by month, compare performance to a 3-month rolling average, and identify which lead sources and reactivation methods (calls, email nurture, reminders, etc.) are producing the best outcomes.

Q4. What is a good way to visualize this KPI for weekly coaching?
A trend view by month paired with a rolling average makes it easy to see momentum. The key insight is whether performance is trending above or below your recent baseline, which helps you coach the right behavior quickly.

Q5. Why does the video use minimum counts before analyzing results?
Because small sample sizes can mislead you. If a lead source or follow-up method only has a handful of reactivations, the close rate can swing wildly. Setting a minimum threshold helps you focus on patterns that are statistically meaningful.

Q6. Where can I get the dataset used in the tutorial?
You can download the file using the link near the video. If you can’t find it, the video also explains how to request it by email so you can follow along exactly.

Get more lessons like this
by joining our newsletter

Receive weekly Excel tutorials, tips, and KPIs straight to your inbox

Databoards

Analysis & Development